Showing posts with label J Walker Smith. Show all posts
Showing posts with label J Walker Smith. Show all posts

Mar 20, 2019

Kantar’s 5 Operating Principles for Understanding Consumer Behavior

J. Walker Smith, Chief Knowledge Officer, Kantar, has seen the media ecosystem shift as overall transformations and changing consumer behaviors place different challenges to brands. “The largest companies in the world are experiencing no topline growth,” he said. But while “the macro forces have changed, lifestyle and needs have changed,” companies for the most part, he noted, haven’t moved out of their comfort zones.

Through recent research at Kantar, Walker Smith recommends five new operating principles to better understand consumer behaviors. They all begin with a number:
  • 679 which is the number of unique foundation colors available at cosmetics counters in stores. This is 25% more choice than was available a few years ago and demonstrates the increasing fragmentation of consumer tastes in the market. Products and services are becoming more personalized and customized, and not just in consumer products. The number of most popular music genres increased from 35 in the 1960s to 99 today. The takeaway from all of this? Opportunities will be found in niche markets not mass markets. Bigger business at smaller scale.

  • 286% which is the return to shareholders on the value of trust, demonstrating the actual economic value of trust. Sadly, this valuable attribute has seen a decline among consumers over the past decade. Big brand messaging is not working any longer as consumers rely on those they know for recommendations. Trust does not come from authority today. It comes from more personal recommendations. We are moving from institutional to intimate.

  • Magical number 7, give or take two. This represents our short term memory; the average number of things we can remember at one time. Knowing that the human brain can retain only so much at one time, why do we push more and more ads? The average number of ads pushed today are double what it was in 2008, outpacing consumers capacity to retain the message. So the lesson here is that we should be enabling opt in to retain brand clarity.

  • 500k likes refers to the transition to recommendations by algorithms. Humans are seeking more down time from tech, as evidenced by the resurgence of many analogue goods such as books, vinyl LPs and instant photography. Seeking the human touch will only accelerate with the advancements in voice technology.

  • 90% of consumers value experiences over material possessions. Since the fastest growing part of the consumer economy is experiences, it’s the savvy marketer who increases the experience over the possession. An example is CapOne bank creating a coffee shop in its branches. This has proved so popular that the bank is rolling this out nationally.

Following these five principles will help companies better navigate the ever changing terrain by allowing for a greater understanding of consumer behaviors, says Smith. Sometimes it’s just simple arithmetic.

Nov 21, 2018

Figuring Out the Impact of Algoritms. An Interview with Kantar’s J Walker Smith


Algorithms’ impact on the media marketplace “are more prevalent than people realize, although not nearly as prevalent as it will be soon,” according to J. Walker Smith, Kantar’s Chief Knowledge Officer. 

And he should know. He is in the business of monitoring “the shifting dynamics of the marketplace context within which consumers live and shop.” Now, with a media measurement industry that is increasingly moving towards artificial intelligence and algorithms, his work is involving more of these technologies.

Charlene Weisler: How prevalent is the impact of algorithms and AI on the marketplace?

J. Walker Smith: It is important to distinguish algorithms and AI.  Algorithms are structured decision rules that, nowadays, are executed through software used to run automated marketing programs or consumer apps.  AI consists of learning systems that modify and (hopefully) improve algorithms or decision rules over time.  AI is still being tested and assessed, although we hear a lot about many of its big early successes.  Algorithms are the beating heart of programmatic marketing and real-time targeting, and they are the way in which all kinds of apps work.  Algorithms make the matches for dating software, figure out which cars are available that meet your preferences and which new music your streaming service pushes at you.  They determine which movies to suggest you watch or additional products you might want to add to your basket.  Looking ahead, predictive software systems will get better at profiling consumers (within regulatory restrictions about data) and matching inventory to individual profiles.  Personalization or customization is a process driven by algorithms.

Weisler: What are the positive and negative aspects of this?

Smith: An enormous amount of time and money is wasted on bad matches.  Nobody wants to spend money on a product that isn't a good fit or waste time learning something that is a bad fit.  Nobody wants to get entangled in a bad relationship that could have been avoided with an algorithm.  Economists care about this because they study efficiencies and bad matches are a drag on the economy.  It's hard to measure, but economists can point to things like people finding jobs faster and being better matched as direct improvements to macroeconomic welfare.  The negative aspects are two-fold.  First, people like to choose and to be involved in deciding.  An algorithm that does everything for you takes away the pleasure of discovery.  However, this can be solved with future software that builds in discovery.  People can also control themselves by using algorithms to aid decisions rather than to make decisions.  We refer to this as the "algorithmically enabled consumer" — using algorithms to make better, smarter, more satisfying decisions.  The second thing to protect against is data security.  Algorithms require data about consumers, so considerations of data privacy are front and center.  Activists and regulators are more worried about this than the typical consumer, though.  I believe we will eventually reach an equilibrium point, and then from there, consumers will still want algorithms that can predict or aid in decision-making.

Weisler: How fast will it grow?

Smith: It's growing fast and is very prevalent already.  There are no good metrics to track algorithms per se, but the take-off rate of the Internet of Things is the best proxy, because algorithms will be embedded in all of these devices.  Thye are in every consumer app too and that has become the new interface for content and products.  So, the question of how fast it will grow is a bit of looking backwards because algorithms are already present en masse.

Weisler: Can algorithms be "gamed" and if so, how?

Smith: Everything can be gamed.  You game algorithms by figuring out the inputs and the relative value an equation places on each input.  This is how people have tried to game Google, and it's why Google keeps upgrading its algorithm.  Indeed, gaming algorithms will become a large part of tomorrow's marketing landscape — not to do anything inappropriate or illegal, but to increase exposure to consumers and to boost the likelihood of consumers choosing one brand over another.  If this sounds familiar, it's because this is what marketers have always tried to do — not necessarily by gaming something, but just by putting more effort and money into the things that are known to work best in getting consumers to choose one brand over another.

Weisler: Algorithms can be wrong - what can a consumer do in that case?

Smith: In fact, algorithms are wrong a lot.  Marketers play the odds, looking to increase the likelihood of consumers choosing their brand—and they want to do so affordably.  Structured decision rules to accomplish this have always been embedded in media buying equations and marketing rules-of-thumb.  Algorithms are just the 21st century version of that.  So being wrong per se is not bad for marketers, as long as they are being wrong less frequently by using an algorithm.  For consumers, they must apply nothing more than normal diligence.  Consumers also know that many decisions will be less than optimal, so a good algorithm is one that minimizes not eliminates bad choices.  Algorithmic mistakes are not life-threatening, at least not yet, so for consumers, wrong outcomes are just an inconvenience. 

Weisler: How do they evolve?

Smith: Algorithms evolve through experience that improves the models embedded in the algorithmic system.  This can be done periodically over time or it can be done in real-time.  Validations are run to assess predictions and then once enough data has been accumulated, updates are made.  The latter is the AI future that is getting so much press.  By the way, the next frontier of evolution is voice assistants.  Algorithms will be a big part of voice-based systems, but this is just in its initial stages right now.

Weisler: What can marketers do to not only prepare but excel?

Smith: Marketers need to learn to operate and change their own systems more quickly.  The battleground in digital is better data and better models, which is to say, better algorithms.  For the algorithms that consumers use, marketers must learn how to be responsive to their systems and how to build these systems into their understanding of the consumer decision journey.  Right now, marketers implicitly assume that it's the same ol' consumer taking in information and making decisions.  Yet increasingly, it is consumers using algorithms to do that, so algorithms are the audience not consumers.  Marketers must learn how to "advertise to algorithms," as we like to say.

Weisler: What types of datasets are needed to get started? To progress?

Smith: We need better databases of consumer profile data, better databases of in-market response to advertising and promotions, real-time databases of actual choices or searching or consideration or queries, better validation databases of actual outcomes and more servers and processing power to use algorithms that can perform and take actions in real-time.

Weisler: Doesn’t this type of marketing lead to "fishing in the same pool" for consumers. What about potential customers who may not know about your product or service?

Smith: There is nothing new about this with algorithms.  In fact, algorithms are about standing out in this crowded pool, and so are a new source of competitive advantage and a new kind of barrier to entry.  Algorithms are not simply about marketing to past consumers or modeling past behavior.  Going after existing customers is profitable when done well, but marketers are aware that they have to grow their franchise and the category itself. 

This article first appeared in www.Mediapost.com

Mar 25, 2013

Getting in the Flow State at the ARF Re:Think 2013



One of the best research-oriented conferences in the industry is the ARF Re-Think 2013 which just concluded in NYC this past week. 

"Re-Think" is an appropriate word to describe the role of research in the media industry today. Research is no longer the corporate function that we have known for the past 30+ years. Now Research has evolved into a range of disciplines from analytics, strategic insights, big data miners and even storytellers. Ask someone in research where the greatest challenges are and they will tend to cite some form of measurement whether cross platform, brand differentiation, market mix modeling, panel representativeness, aggregating layers of information about consumers’ lives, measurement at scale,  duplication and keeping up with technology.

View the range of responses here in a video taken at the ARF Re:Think 2013 conference.


Change is occurring in all aspects of the media landscape. According to keynote speaker J Walker Smith of the Futures Company, it is now the best of times and the worst of times for brand marketers. Between the extremes of the rise of the digital age that makes our lives more connected and the outrage over societal ills that divide us, there is a kinship economy formed by global rage and a crisis of leadership. What this means is that consumers are buying locally, buying less and forming attitudes that are less favorable to global brands. In some cases they are avoiding certain companies entirely. Their reference points are changing from aspirational to survivalist and they are breaking away from big authority and forming their own thought leader groups among their peers.
 
This impacts brand engagement. In the old model, it is the brand that engages the consumer. Now brands are advocated by people interacting with other people in the social media environment. Some advertisers are jumping into this new ecosystem and succeeding such as Amex Sync and Nike. They are creating opportunities for consumers to interconnect and create social currency to spend. We are never going back to the old way, Smith concludes. Brands must evolve or suffer.

A thought provoking presentation by lunch keynote Steven Kotler of the Flow Genome Project offered a provocative appraisal of what constitutes happiness. Happiness, he postulated, is measureable. And our states of happiness often occur in what he calls Flow States - those meditative, "finding your groove" times when the world seems in sync, the creative process expands and intellectual performance improves. Flow, Kotler noted, is becoming increasingly important to businesses and ways are being developed to measure group flow in the workplace.

Between the personal chi of flow and the external push of kinship economy, how can one ride along with the change before it steamrolls you? Kathy McGettrick of IBM advised to stay updated with the trends and organizationally bring social and analytic experts into the Research function. She said it would help to become an insights alchemist – someone who combines raw materials together to create gold. Research companies need to be nimble and need to be, as Nielsen’s Paul Donato said, "conspicuously innovative" and as Wharton’s Jerry Wind warned to ”avoid the traditional arrogance of traditional companies” and “start to experiment.” Mark Truss on JWT suggested a 1% challenge: “Take 1% of the Research budget and use it for experimentation. Try and fail and learn from failure and move on. Volunteer for new experiences.” All very sage advice.

The range of research innovation presented at the conference was heartening from ESPN’s Blueprint cross platform measurement to CBS’ segmentation of Media Trendsetters and Program Passionates to NBCU’s blending of Comcast STB data with authenticated online tablet and VOD data to the range of neuroscience based companies quantifying eye tracking on the various platforms.

Ultimately, I walked away from Re:Think 2013 convinced that as the future “flows”, it is our job to keep up to date … as well as up to the data.